|
The 7th Green at Downfield
Course report from Sports Turf Research Institiute
Downfield Golf Club
Spring Agronomy Report
Report Date: 26.04.10
The STRI Agronomy and Advisory service is designed
to assist clients in understanding the best way to
manage their sports facilities. All
recommendations made by STRI are impartial, with no
affiliation to any manufacturer, supplier or
contractor.
STRI
Downfield Golf Club
Spring Agronomy Report
Date of Visit
Monday 26 th
April 2010
Visit Objective
To review the spring condition of the course and
confirm spring and summer maintenance operations
Present
Mr David Hart – Green Convener
Mr Paul Murphy – Course Manager
Mr Richard Windows – Turfgrass Agronomist, STRI
Ltd.
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Despite a very cold
winter the course emerged into the spring with a good
cover of grass to all playing surfaces. Cold
temperatures and easterly winds recently have hampered
early season growth.
Light foliar feeds through March and April
have encouraged some growth despite the cold weather.
These have also helped provide slightly smoother
surfaces than previous springs.
Drainage was installed to the 17 th
green. Some additional rolling
and top dressing is required to smooth and perfect
this surface for the main season.
The maintenance programme at Downfield is
excellent and produces very high quality putting
surfaces during favourable summer conditions. However,
playing qualities and turf condition quickly
deteriorates during wet weather and more generally
through the early spring months. The limiting factor
on year round performance of the greens is due to the
poor drainage qualities of the underlying soils and
shaded environment around many greens. To improve year
round performance we must look to improve drainage and
improve light and airflow around the greens.
As part of the upgraded agronomy service, the
STRI Programme (involving objective measurements) will
be integrated into all future agronomy visits. This
will identify where improvements are required, allow
maintenance targets to be set and provide a measure of
progress in response to maintenance over time.
We are delighted to see greens maintenance
being extended into the surrounds and approaches to
greens as well as a lower mowing height being adopted
to these areas. .
The coarse textured perennial ryegrass
remains an issue to green surrounds on 5, 7 and 13. A
renovation programme will be formulated for these
areas during the late summer. However, if this is
unsuccessful re-turfing with high quality imported
fescue/bent dominant turf will be required through the
autumn/winter.
The 4 th
surround and approach remains weak and
suffered during the wet autumn weather. The turf has
subsequently thinned and will require significant
renovation this spring to restore grass cover. Now
that drainage has been installed a similar level of
deterioration in the future should be avoided.
The 4 th
fairway requires intensive sand top
dressing along with some feeding to boost growth and
improve the consistency of lies and surface drainage.
One or two weak areas of fairways following
winter damage was present (e.g. 1 and 2), which will
require some overseeding and feeding over the
forthcoming weeks.
2.0 GREENS
2.1 Observations & Review
As organic matter levels in the upper soil profile
were identified as being slightly high last autumn,
following the wet weather over the past two years, an
intensive thatch removal and top dressing programme
was formulated and implemented during October. This
involved hollow coring using 19mm tines followed by
the application of approximately 50 tonnes of sand to
the greens. While this work went well, the late
implementation of the work has meant the holes remain
present throughout the winter and some of the weaker
surfaces are still to recover. For this reason, hollow
coring, albeit less intensive, should be implemented
much earlier (ideally around July) to optimise
recovery, minimise disruption to golf and improve the
results from the operation.
Due to sound maintenance operations, turf health
and vigour was good going into the cold period of
weather that commenced in mid December. Due to the
shaded nature of some greens and the populations of
annual meadow grass to these surfaces, there was a
concern that the very cold weather and prolonged snow
cover may have resulted in significant damage to the
turf. Pleasingly this was not the case as the turf was
strong and well conditioned going into this cold
period of weather. Consequently all the surfaces
except the 6 th
emerged from this cold weather with a
strong cover of grass going into the early spring. The
6th did
suffer from a greater intensity of fusarium damage and
has been appropriately plugged to aid the rapid
restoration of grass cover to this green.
Some sections of greens which held water during the
autumn/winter have lost grass cover, e.g. rear of 11
and right of 15. These will be renovated over the
forthcoming weeks.
So far this spring five applications of potassium
nitrate fertiliser have been applied as a foliar feed
through March and April to encourage early season
growth and help improve early spring playing
qualities. This programme has been successful and a
significantly stronger cover of grass was considered
to be present in comparison to previous years. A
couple of top dressing applications have been made
through March and April with regular Turf Iron rolling
to optimise smoothness, trueness and early season
pace. Some of the stronger greens (e.g. 9 and 18) have
had some light verti-cutting to refine the bent grass
component of the sward. As growth is now picking up,
the main granular feed shall be applied to the weaker
greens to help the
hollow core holes fill in and facilitate the
appropriate sward refinement operations to polish the
greens in anticipation of the main season.
Photograph 1: Thin turf is present to areas which
retained water through the winter e.g. rear of the 11 th
green
The installation of pipe drainage was successfully
completed to the 17 th
green. However, the aeration work prior
to the drainage installation did make the turf rather
difficult to lift and re-lay. So, if this programme of
work is extended to other greens in the future,
avoiding any sort of aeration prior to re-turfing will
of course be beneficial.
2.2 Discussion
As we have discussed in previous reports ,
and during the recent visit,
the maintenance programme implemented at Downfield is
first class. The progress made over the past 10-15
years in improving botanical composition, year round
consistency,
reducing chemical inputs and
ultimately providing high quality putting surfaces
during favourable weather conditions is an example to
other similar inland clubs. There is no doubt the
standards that are achieved at Downfield during
favourable weather conditions
provide
some of the best inland greens
in Scotland. We simply need to sustain the current
maintenance programme with some ongoing fine tuning to
sustain the high standards currently achieved.
However, as we have observed over the past 2-3
years (essentially since LFQ in 2007) the greens
quickly deteriorate in terms of playing quality and
turf condition during the winter and, in fact, during
any periods of prolonged wet weather. The heavy and
poor drainage performance of underlying soils combined
with the heavily shaded nature of many of the greens
being the primary reasons for such poor performance in
wet weather.
The reconstruction of the 4 th,
12th and
pipe drainage to the 17th
green is a positive step to improve the
performance of these greens but, we really should
extend similar strategies to the other greens around
the course over the next few years. In addition, it is
essential we implement more tree thinning and removal
work (see photograph 3) around many greens to improve
light and airflow, which is an essential pre-requisite
for healthy turf and year round playability.
A serious discussion regarding these issues should
be made internally to allow an appropriate management
plan and budget for the works to be developed. We are
Downfield Golf Club 5
confident the greens will not improve beyond the
standards currently achieved unless this more
intensive work is implemented.
Photograph 2: Further tree removal is required to
the rear of the 17 th
green
2.3 Objective Measurements
As the STRI Programme has been integrated into
routine agronomy visits to Downfield, we took
objective measurements of the key playing qualities of
greens speed, surface smoothness, trueness and
firmness during the visit. To provide a representation
of the different construction types and parts of the
course we selected greens to 1, 12 and 17 for
objective measurements.
By measuring the playing qualities, we can
accurately assess the standards being set and also
compare them to our ideal. As we stated in previous
reports, Downfield is a high class parkland course so
we aim to create a consistent set of firm, smooth,
true well paced and authentic surfaces that remain
consistent throughout the year regardless of the
weather conditions.
As part of the STRI Programme service, the playing
qualities of the greens can be recorded by the
Greenstaff and collated on the STRI extranet
throughout the year. This information, combined with
that recorded during STRI agronomy visits, will be
presented with the aid of simple graphics and will...
Provide a running commentary of green
performance throughout the year.
Assess consistency between greens.
Inform maintenance decision making.
Identify the strengths and weaknesses of the
existing maintenance programme and allow accurate fine
tuning where necessary.
This objective approach to greenkeeping and
agronomy essentially allows a more accurate
greenkeeping plan to be formulated and implemented to
ensure our playing quality targets are met. The
following table illustrates the results from the
indicator greens collected in the visit.
Downfield Golf Club 6
|
Downfield
Golf Club |
|
Objective
measurement results |
|
Hardness
|
Green speed
|
VWC
|
Smoothness
|
Trueness
|
Word picture
|
|
1
|
77
|
7 ft 2 in
|
41.7
|
17.9
|
12.3
|
5.9
|
|
1 rolled
|
n/a
|
8 ft 0 in
|
n/a
|
14.9
|
9.7
|
6.4
|
|
12
|
103
|
7 ft 5 in
|
25.0
|
19.6
|
10.9
|
5.8
|
|
17
|
86
|
6 ft 6 in
|
27.8
|
20.4
|
11.7
|
5.7
|
Archive News
Friday the 1st May 2009
saw the 4th hole opened for play after huge construction.
The green and most of the fairway inside 120 yards was
lifted and rebuilt. There are discussions about the
re-bunkering of the entire hole in the near future but the
exact positioning of them is being looked at by our course
architect, David J Russell. The greens committee will then
decide if this will make the hole a better challenge for
all players. There have been some drainage issues in the
fairway and extra drainage channels have been put in.
These channels will be seeded and should solve any future
problems even if rainfall continues to increase.
At present the big issue
for all inland courses is how to make them cope better
with the extreme rainfall we are getting.
2008 saw the second phase of our course redesign work being carried out by Paul Murphy and his staff. They changed the surface on the 12th green in 2006 to allow for better drainage and to encourage stronger grasses to thrive. In late 2007-early 2008 we joined forces with David J Russell from RAW Golf Design to set out a re-bunkering programme to bring the course "up to date". At present the 10th, 13th and 15th have seen some bunker work. The 4th hole has been redesigned and the green rebuilt to a very high specification. It is nearly finished it's makeover as the green has been the cause of some major problems for the last couple of years. Although many say it is one of our best par 5's, it will be made even into one of the best par 5's in the country. The work is finished now with the Gelly burn re-routed slightly and a
small pond put in short right of the new green. New
bunkering near the
green will take place in winter 2009.
The removal of some of
our larger trees around the 5th green has proved to be a
huge success with the green transformed and looking very
healthy even into late autumn
|
|